Quantcast

Betty's Blog

Timely Teacher Talk

Sponsored Links

My Lesson Plans

Are longer school years really necessary?

I love summer vacation.  As a teacher, the lazy days always gave me a chance to recharge and get excited about a new group of students.  My mind could relax and come up with new teaching ideas.  My own kids had a chance to take swimming lessons, and we took some wonderful family trips.  Some educators feel that the summer vacation should be cut even more.  Longer school years can provide more learning time.  Would this mean higher test scores?

A longer school year may become a reality for many American kids. Some Massachusetts school districts want to add 20 more days to the school year. And an Indiana state senator recently proposed a bill that would add three more weeks of class time for Indiana students by 2010.

Ben Q., 14, attends the Latin School of Chicago and says he doesn't feel a longer year is necessary for the students at his school. "I think everyone learns well with the time given," he says.

Ben and his classmates receive assignments over the summer. He says he has to read several books and write essays. But when school begins in the fall, his class doesn't have to spend too much time reviewing last year's lessons. "For the first week [we review], and then it's full force into new subjects and new matters," Ben says.

When I was a kid, we had all of June, July, and August off and usually didn't return to school until after Labor Day.  We were encouraged to read during the summer, but there were never any required assignments.  There weren't any big tests that we had to pass to prove that our teachers were doing a good job.  My sister and I spent our summers picking bagworms off of the cedar trees, riding our bikes, and making our own paper dolls.  We recently found the shoe box containing all of the paper dolls we had made during those glorious summers.  Hopefully, we won't find any of the bagworms.  One time we picked a whole trash can full of the critters and stupidly placed the can with its wiggling contents back in the bathroom.  Later that day, my sister came running out of the bathroom screaming because the worms had crawled out and were hanging from the walls and ceiling.  Maybe longer school years could have helped us after all!

Posted: Wednesday, April 18, 2007 1:10 PM by Betty
Comments

jtspencer said:

I think that you and your sister probably learned valuable lessons from pulling worms and riding bikes.  Chances are, they were just as valuable as diagraming sentences or dividing fractions.  

I think students and teachers need a break.  The time of rest is part of what makes us continue to pour all of our energy into what we do.

# April 19, 2007 8:39 AM

MysteryTeacher said:

I object to lengthening the year.  Unless they give us 2 or 3 week breaks in the fall, winter, and spring.  It takes too much out of us and when in the heck do we go to school and work on professional development?  I am tired by June.  July is when I have to get my room ready.  We often begin in the end of July.  Teachers Unite!  We need more time to regenerate.

# April 23, 2007 3:14 PM

Kris said:

Longer school years? For whom?  Kids or politicians?  Pretty soon students will no longer be kids.  They'll become mass-produced products of an educational system bent on adding to an already over-stressed society that looks to education to solve all of its ills.  Let kids be kids.  Concentrate on the quality of time that we have with them now, not extra time!

# April 26, 2007 8:33 AM

jrae922 said:

I whole-heartedly agree with Kris.  EVERYONE needs a break.  With all the new pressures for students and teachers in schools, shortening their summer time will only result in a quicker burnout for all involved.  In addition, more time does not necessisarily mean better time.  Valuable learning and experiences take place for kids during summer vacation as well.  Just because they are not in a classroom following a curriculum does not mean that they are not learning.  And obviously teachers need the relaxation and prep time as well.

# May 2, 2007 3:22 PM
New Comments to this post are disabled.