Quantcast

Betty's Blog

Timely Teacher Talk

Sponsored Links

Students are individuals

Thursday night was a biggie for newscasters.  "Shocking study reveals" that girls are just as good at math as boys."  Actually, they didn't give that much info prior to the actual story.  The teasers for this story made me think that I was going to be blown away. 

As a sixth grade math teacher for fifteen years, I can truthfully say that I never even wondered if girls or boys were better at math.  Students are individuals.  It doesn't matter what gender or race they are.  They are people with unique talents, concerns, worries, and personalities.  Some of my students did exceptionally well in math.  Others struggled.  We were all in it together and learned from each other. 

Every year I had a team of sixth graders enter the district math competition.  It never occurred to me to seek out only males for my team.  The first criteria for me was the desire a student had to be a team member.  All were eligible to attend our after school sessions.  Students worked together on problem solving and laughed when their solutions were way off the mark.  Eventually, a little team would form for the competition.  One year we actually came in first place and beat out a team from a gifted school.  I couldn't tell you now how many girls or how many boys were on that team.  

The study itself bothers me because I just don't think that way.  Making a big deal about girls performing as well as boys in math seems like one of those "duh" moments to me.  Thinking of students as individuals makes a lot more sense. 

Posted: Saturday, July 26, 2008 9:15 AM by Betty
Filed under:

Comments

Veggie Mom said:

Hey there! Please join our campaign to e-mail Oprah. We're counting on our readers to pull out all the stops for Uncle Lynn & Pop'rs! Pop'rs on Oprah--how cool would that be? I'm keeping my fingers crossed...

# July 26, 2008 4:10 PM

Teresa_Thompson said:

Betty,

The sudy just shows math success as an average. Of course you may have a different experience. Anecdotal evidence never proves or disproves anything.

You may not "think" that way, BUT historically girls do less well in math subjects than boys do. it isn't becuase girls are less intelligent but that girls have generally been guided toward more domestic paths that do not require a intense knowledge of math or science. So when girls get into math we are kind of programmed to believe we aren't going to do well.

Now that we have more girls and women breaking the mold and stereotype you are going to see more girls and women succeeding in math.

And yeah, it really is a no brainer :)

PS- I for one am glad you are a teacher who sees passed these gender steotypes. Awesome!

# July 26, 2008 9:52 PM

MsP said:

Betty, I agree completely that we should look at students as individuals. Unfortunately, THE TEST, likes to break everything down into economic status, race, special ed, bilingual, esl, etc. I have such a hard time with this sometimes. I have had principals say, "Ok, how many african american children do you have? How many hispanic? Asian? White?" We've even had to listen to them debate about whether a child from Russia is considered "asian". I really have to stop and think about it because I just don't view them that way. They are kids. They are my students. I don't care what color they are or what their economic status is becasue we are all in the process of learning to our best abilitiies. I guess I just don't see what that has to do with any child's ability to learn or pass THE TEST. Maybe if they quit focusing so much on that stuff and would give us the support we need, we would be able to better meet the needs of all students, even if they are purple with pink polkadots. :^)

# July 27, 2008 8:00 AM

Veggie Mom said:

I'm uncomfortable myself, lumping kids all in one group--boys vs. girls, blacks vs. whites--and I especially abhor tracking for intelligence. I wish we'd just get over all this "teaching to the test" and just get back to teaching! But enough of these serious issues for today--BTW, it's that time of week again--please drop on in for a little Silly Summer Sunday Sweepstakes. You have 2 chances to play!

# July 27, 2008 3:52 PM

Melissa B. said:

OK--I'm not sure how my comment above got all tangled up with Veggie Mom--Blogger has been going CRAZY all day! Don't know if it's my computer or what! Anyway I'M the one sponsoring Silly Summer Sunday. So there! :)

# July 27, 2008 3:55 PM

JCK said:

I just don't know what these people are thinking--I can't for the life of me understand why they throw these studies around, as if any of it truly proves anything at all...(OK, OK, I'll put the soap box away!) All I am saying is if they ever stop to get feedback on these ridiculous stories, all they would get from teachers is a big, fat Noooo,  REALLY?  

# July 27, 2008 6:39 PM

Dominic said:

I whole-heartedly agree with you JCK!

# July 27, 2008 9:01 PM

Jessica said:

I am a undergraduate student at Auburn University in elementary education and I want to say that I completely agree that students are individuals. When I was in school I felt that I as a girl was not as smart as boys were. It was just a notion that I got from the way boys were treated and the way girls were treated. I can't say that anyone in particular made me feel that way but for some reason and somewhere along the way I gained that understanding and I have kept it with me until I got to college. I don't know what the studies say but I believe that society has created this stereotype.

# July 27, 2008 9:04 PM
New Comments to this post are disabled.