Quantcast
An educational community
to connect teachers from every level.
Welcome to Teacher Lingo Sign in | Join | Help
in Search
     

Mysterious Teaching

Insights behind the perils of being a teacher

The future of the world.

I have read several books lately that deal with what the world will be like AFTER the big one.  I don't know if it is a good idea for young people to read this kind of book.  Yet, they are all written for Tweens.  The City of Ember is the latest one I read.  It was sad, scarey and disturbing.  I would have hated to read that book as a kid.  I love mysteries where everything goes wrong but I don't think I want my little ones to even think about a world that survives after a global disaster.

Of course in these books, it is always the kids who "save the day".  Ember is an underground city where a group of people were hidden before the final disaster happened.  Scientists knew it was coming.  In the end, they ran out of everything and had to leave but no one knew how to get out.

In the sequel, the people above ground hate and mistrust the cave people.  They are cruel, deceptive and unfriendly.  Do kids really need this kind of material?  We try to teach tolerance, sharing, caring, and love and to read a book like this destroyed all of these emotions.  This book talks about getting even, stealing because they feel cheated, and going crazy.  I just feel very uncomfortable with it.

What bothers me the most in these books is that God disappeared in all of their disasters.  What makes them think that God would allow that to happen?  Why does an author think that faith is dispensable along with all of the worldly things. What a very sad life they have without the knowledge of God.  These books make me very sad.

Published Saturday, October 27, 2007 5:33 PM by MysteryTeacher

Comments

 

KatTXteacher said:

It is good that we read books before our students, for that exact reason. I'm glad you saw what other kids are going to be reading at some point...hopefully if they ever do read it we can just explain it to them and guide them through it. That does sound sad and I will try and avoid that... :-)

October 27, 2007 10:47 PM
 

Betty said:

I would never want to read books like that.  The sad thing is that they will probably become popular and be made into movies.  Yuck!  You are right KatTXteacher about reading books ahead of time.  It may take a little extra time, but it's well worth it.

October 28, 2007 7:38 AM
New Comments to this post are disabled. 


About MysteryTeacher

I am 53 years old and have been teaching for 20 years this year. I have two daughters and two grandaughters and two son-in-laws, all of whom I adore. I love to travel with friends but I am now saving for retirement in about 14 years. I am becoming technologically educated. Since digital is the 21st century than I believe that teachers should too. We need to be educated enough to understand our students. I have a teaching degree, a masters degree, an ESL endorsement and a Gifted endorsement.

This Blog

Sponsored Links

Syndication