TeacherLingo.com is an educational community where teachers share their worksheets, lesson plans, printables and other original teaching resources.

Teaching Resources created and sold by real teachers.

Login to TeacherLingo.com        Create Account on TeacherLingo.com
Visitors are welcome to view but to post you will need to register first. Registration is free and only takes a minute.
Please remember to follow our Terms of Use.


Last post 04-22-2009, 3:15 PM by StudentHandoutsInc. 1 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  04-18-2009, 2:28 PM 217136

    WHY ESL?

    • I am looking for people who will discuss the pros and cons of spending public tax dollars teaching non-English speakers to speak English. Why do we spend this money. Why should it not be a requirement that a child speak English before he is allowed to enroll in a public school? For that matter, should it not be a requirement for a green card?

      I'm just askin" Talk to me!

    There are "NO" bad kids.

    If the student fails to learn, the teacher failed to teach.
  •  04-22-2009, 3:15 PM 218513 in reply to 217136

    Re: WHY ESL?

    In a way, widespread, mandatory public education began as "ESL". 

    At the turn of the last century, schools were established nationwide--and schooling became a requirement--as a response to growing numbers of immigrants.  Education (and the learning of English) was a way to "americanize" immigrant children.  Schooling remains largely an "americanizing" institution today.  Kids learn about the history of the United States, and say the Pledge of Allegiance every morning.

    The Supreme Court has ruled that ESL services be provided to all students, and that schools do not have the right to demand proof of citizenship or resident alien status.

    A lot of educators point out that demands regarding English proficiency are potentially unfair.  For example, were all immigrants required to be fluent English speakers, immigration would be largely limited to immigrants from English-speaking countries (that is, white people). 

    As for students, children are required by law to attend school.  Keeping ESL students out of school would break that law.  It would also keep ESL kids behind other students, since English is not the only subject taught in school.  An ESL kid kept out of school would earn English very slowly at home (if at all), and would have next to no opportunities to learn math and other subjects.  What would become of such a child when she or he grows up?

    Are you currently confronted with the challenges of teaching an ESL student?


    100% Free Teaching Materials Online - No Sign-Up Needed - Visit: Student Handouts
View as RSS news feed in XML